There are no hard lines here.
ardour.org is (currently) hosted on AWS. Does that give us “the practical and ethical problems of corporate software” ?
The main post laid out a series of points about the downsides of AI that is very similar to Wiedauer’s. What I’m trying to get to is a useful, productive way to connect the downsides and the upsides. I don’t find it sufficient to say “but these downsides are so terrible, no possible upside could justify them”. It may well be that the downsides outweigh the upsides. But it also might not (just as most of us do not protest too much living in a world with lots and lots of internal combustion engines).
Perhaps it would be useful to be highly practical and specific about this. Right now, Linux distributions are steadily deprecating X Window and replacing it with Wayland. The GUI toolkit that we use has no backend for Wayland - writing one is a substantial and challenging task that almost nobody is interested in doing. For Ardour to continue being viable on Linux, then either XWayland has to continue to improve (because right now, it does not provide the same experience as “native X Window” when using Ardour) - this is not guaranteed and we have no meaningful control over whether it does or does not happen - or we need a Wayland backend.
Would that “threat” to Ardour’s continued viability justify using a coding agent/harness such as Claude to write that Wayland backend?