This is simply not true! It still is no match of Water and energy consumption of most expensive ai-data-centers needed to run a Hopefuly-Maybe ok-software developed by a computer program! Besides, just my personal opinion: I would never buy/donate a program I know is developed by some AI! At most I would give it a FREE try ![]()
You just like to think you archived something…guess what, you didn’t, Claude did.
That isn’t nuanced enough. It’s a team effort.
In the case of that bestseller, who exactly had that profound style, who exactly was such an elegant storyteller?
The inspiration and trajectory of the book was due to its author, Eric Ries. In the book, Eric acknowledged that his elegant expression was greatly enhanced by large language models.
I invite you to judge the work product on its own terms, not so much by how it was created.
Yes, the author wrote probably a prompt: combine every thing you find on best-seller literature on the net, and spit out a salad of all those styles, which might become a best-seller!
Btw, since when being best-seller become a virtue? Every thing which is for the mass can be imitated by AI, agree on that. But search good stuff not on best-seller lists
(the best-seller guy is a Silicon Valley Entrepreneur
)
If you had even read the book description, I bet you would not dismiss it so casually.
I’m not sure it is a virtue, but it does announce a book that stands above other books in some measure. It is not easy to write a best seller.
Sure, I wrote a critique of the book, but I also admire the book for its aspiration.
You know, from a legal standpoint…if something LLMs create cannot be copyrighted, how can something like that book be bestseller
???
That book is basically uncopyrighted until the court(which court by the way?) decides otherwise?
It’s silly.
I won’t argue on this particular subject anymore, it’s completely ridiculous
.
The legal point is more nuanced than you’ve suggested. I described it in the main post. Purely machine-generated anything cannot be copyright, but the courts in various places have made it clear that if a human subsequently “does enough” with whatever the machine generated, it becomes copyrightable by that human(s).
The courts have not defined what “enough” is, however.
I could write some pretty elegant prose as well if I could synthesize James Baldwin, Ernest Hemingway, JRR Tolkien, CS Lewis, Frank Herbert, Maya Angelou, Aldous Huxley, Dickens, Stephen King etc… etc… etc…
There is vast difference between overseeing and authoring…
IMO, that would be exceeedingly unlikely to become a best-seller. If you look over best seller lists (pick whichever one you want), I think you’ll find that although there are occasionally books that make it into the lists that people roll their eyes at, for the most part the list contents are dominated by well-written, well-imagined, well-told stories that are more often than not quite original in a number of ways.
Also, something to keep in mind: the median number of copies sold of books published in the USA is around 1000. There are strong outliers, and an argument to be made that certain categories of books should be excluded from the numbers used to do this comparison. Nevertheless, outside of a handful (literally single-digit hundreds of books per year), most books do not sell in “significant” quantities no matter how they were written.
Yeah i know, my memory isn’t deteriorating that significantly yet
… i said it just to firmly point to legal issues as well. I just can’t argue about authoring with people who “create” with generative AI tools and then take on a role of this supposed magnificent author anymore. It was bad enough with all unintentional & intentional plagiarism even before AI era.
You said it somewhere yourself - when it comes to programming applications, one could argue that you’re just speeding up the process of creation of a tool for people to use, and that in itself, kind of, makes it ok (at least from the user perspective…but i suspect it’s gonna be really demotivating for the dev in the long run). But, when it comes to art, i just don’t understand it at all…Who&why on Earth has the motivation to “create” that way, and why would anyone pay attention to that kind of creation…i just can’t spend any more time thinking & arguing about that … it’s draining, soul sucking, pointless.
…and i could be a great guitarist if i only understood everything that Dexter Gordon did understand
.
But sure as hell i could prompt it…
…there you go, done.
![]()
Why would I bother to read something you couldn’t be bothered to write?
You misunderstand what is going on. Here’s what I might prompt:
- Flow: “Read as a first-time reader. Where does one paragraph fail to set up the next? Suggest bridge sentences or a reordering.”
- Redundancy: “In , find claims or examples that repeat each other or earlier chapters. Propose cuts or short back-references.”
- Unpacking: “Which sentences in carry too many ideas or use undefined terms? Break them down and suggest where to add a definition or restatement.”
- Examples: “Suggest three fresh, concrete examples for the point in . Avoid ones used in RUBB or stahl-2026.txt.”
- Coherence: “Map the argument in as premises, inferences, and conclusion. Flag gaps, unsupported leaps, shifts in meaning, and the strongest skeptical objection.”
Also, just like humans, if the AI reads an updated passage then it often has different, nuanced recommendations to improve more. So I often do the same prompt 10-20 times on a passage as I improve it gradually. I don’t stop until it runs out of good suggestions. This is how I can approach really extraordinary writing.
I feel like Eric Ries did okay with polishing his book, but could have polished it even further. ![]()
So you’re using it like a proof-reader?
More than a proofreader. It can proofread okay, but these other analyses go way beyond what a proofreader can offer.
But I do want to acknowledge that human beta readers can contribute a perspective that AI can’t.
Rather than commenting directly on the topic of this thread, I’d like to share a bit about my own situation.
I have a background in plugin development and mixing engineering, and I’m currently working on a personal album using Ardour.
Until just a few months ago, I was even more skeptical about AI than many of the AI critics in this thread. As a Korean, it was honestly hard to watch people around me going absolutely crazy over AI. I’m not sure if you know this, but roughly 25% of the entire population in South Korea pays for AI services.
I simply didn’t want anything to do with AI.
Then something happened. ChatGPT effortlessly solved a problem that I had been struggling with for over six months. It was genuinely shocking.
After that, I started revisiting and improving my existing code. It would suggest various approaches based on recent research papers and technical references. Being able to evaluate the alternatives and pick what worked best was incredibly easy.
The plugins I’ve improved this way aren’t intended for distribution, nor are they commercial projects. They’re being developed specifically for use in my own production environment, which makes the results all the more satisfying.
I’ve long wanted to optimize my workflow by having only the features I actually need. But “personalizing” dozens of different plugins to that extent would have been practically impossible without AI.
At this point, I have more than 30 plugins in my Ardour sessions that work exactly the way I want them to — no more, no less.
There’s also the question of cost. I don’t pay for AI services. I’ve never even tried dedicated AI coding tools like Claude. So far, the free version of ChatGPT has been more than sufficient for everything I’ve done.
And finally, I have a feeling that much of the discussion in this thread will become irrelevant in another six months. We’ll probably be living in a very different world by then.
Hurray, everything will be different in 6 months! By now, i got really really bored of our same old ways and looking forward to my UBI! ![]()
(i’m not dissaproving what you said, just kidding)
It has come to the point that i don’t even belive in that nice list of arguments you made (and it sure is a nice list)…
Looks exactly like Gemini’s answer
.
Read my post near the beginning of the thread. Deals with this line of thinking. Specifications are not art.
Read it. Completely true.
Exactly like that.
The whole reason people like Ardour is because it doesn’t have the practical and ethical problems of corporate software. Please don’t change that now.
Please read this article: