Heated topic. Sort of building on what Paul said about being hosted on AWS:
They also use paypal for payments (a name I can’t really dissociate from the “paypal mafia”).
Paul worked as an employee for some time for one of those evil tech bros.
Linux and it’s foundation is basically sustained by all these huge predatory capitalist corporations, some of them even complicit in genocide.
Even NetBSD takes advantage of Google’s summer code camps and whatnot.
And I could go on.
I think there has always been this naive idea of FOSS being something uncorrupted or pristine in it’s source from a very liberal, western point of view. I bet there would even be some other branch of purists that would complain if Linux or other FOSS was, hypothetically, only supported and maintained by governments and states. Even if they were only democratically elected governments.
In contrast, there has also always been a pragmatically positive view of FOSS. Don’t we celebrate that Google invests in the Linux foundation? Why do we do that? Because it’s FOSS. You can scrutinize the code. You can review it. You can copy it and distribute it. No one ends up owning it. It is more sustainable long term. And so forth. So, clearly there is an utilitarian aspect to using Linux where we are at ease knowing those companies provide support but don’t own the foundation, and the code remains free and open-source. I, at least, believe these terrible companies are at least contributing to something that is inherently good.
So, if people generally avoid those big ethical topics that existed even pre-LLMs because of an utilitarian point of view, I wonder what changes with LLMs themselves. Aren’t they a tool, just like Microsoft’s money is? Or Amazon’s? Or Google’s?
ArtCraft certainly brought up many of these ethical dilemmas of open source. It’s totally AI slop, but it’s open source and it does break one of the biggest and ugliest monopolies in the creative industry. Again, it seems odd to be celebrating slop, but that dissonance only exposes how desensitized most inhabitants of the “free-world” actually are about how their tech stack is financed.
Now, I understand another concern people usually have is if LLM generated code will be sustainable once they charge the real price it’s worth. But I think Paul and Robin certainly do know what they are doing and could use it to move forward one or two bits without any future sustainability issues.
I hope these words aren’t read as if I were condoning every unethical corporation, tech or actual human beings in our world, but I do think drawing the line can be too complicated and the ethics of the whole subject seem more nuanced than what I can easily grasp. Insofar, what I believe is: If you are using those tools to create something good, I am all for it. If there is actual human effort behind it, I will actually value it even more. If your tools makes something more accessible to those who have less, I will definitely support it.
I’ve just put huge efforts into remodelling our kitchen/dining/living space and last year I added a steam shower. There’s 6.7kW of (self-installed) PV solar out front. My wife just added a big-ass kiln in the back to expand her steel/mosaic/ceramic sculpture work. Yet you call this a shack???
To go even further off topic, I just saw this lovely quote from Terry Patchett comparing what he called horizontal wealth and vertical wealth:
“But horizontal wealth means not letting your increased income dictate your tastes. You like books and now you have money? Buy more books! Change those catenary bookshelves for good hardwood ones! In my case, build a library extension to your office. And, of course, you buy what will be useful for that most wonderful of pursuits, blind research, which is research without direction for the sheer joy of it.”
It would seem that horizontal wealth requires significantly less money and has the potential to be much more intrinsically fulfilling than vertical wealth.
Which is what I fear we are in grave danger of losing with increased dependency on AI
You like books and now you have money? Buy more books!
Which is great, (but, also I guess if you like GPUs then buy more GPUs… I’m not sure what point I’m making here other than perhaps it should have been obvious from the start that if you give a bunch of nerds a limitless supply of cash, they’ll just build the world’s biggest computers… because obviously - its what they / we do
I’m reminded that when someone asked Terry Pratchet why he had six PC monitors, the response was “because I don’t have room for eight…”
So what’s that, about 1㎡ where you are?
Thank god for the desert.
Now, returning (somewhat) to the main topic…
To potentially address the many moments where you’ve brought-up ‘AI-driven/developed DAW competitors’, here’s something I don’t think I’ve seen mentioned in this thread so far (-but please correct me if I’m wrong): What about just making Ardour pre-built binaries free/gratis at this point?
…
I imagine after all these years you probably have some common (or even rigid) response to such a question, so sorry if I’m out of the loop on this one.
Still, and maybe I’m completely naive here, but I’d guess that your subscribers and monthly donations here would not take that much of a hit (-or perhaps none at all-) if you made the binaries free. –And it’s possible that many new people would appreciate the gesture, and then subscribe.
The fact is, this project has now financially established itself quite modestly (-not to mention whatever other work you guys are getting from Harrison, etc.), and that foundation is probably not going anywhere no matter what you do.
Anyway, I know money’s a touchy subject, so sorry if there’s perspectives/ideas/concerns I’m clearly missing. I just thought it might be interesting to read your (@paul) current thoughts on this.
-J
…
[PS: On the upside, this might also forever remove the need to have to clarify the difference between “free” ((beer)) and “free” ((freedom)) on the IRC. ]
The monthly revenue is split about 60:40 between subscriptions and one-time payments, and I don’t think we could deal with a 40% drop in income. I personally don’t believe that subscriptions would increase to cover that if we removed the one-time payment option. I could obviously be wrong about that, but alas I’m not willing to do the experiment.
We’re close to unique among FLOSS projects in that we are able to basically pay two full time developers plus occasionally pay other contributors, without any corporate involvement of any kind. Given that this is niche software, far from the well-known “internet stack” that tends to be talked about in the context of FLOSS, that’s really quite remarkable, and I’m extremely wary of doing stuff that is basically experimenting with that.
Also, remember that before 2009, Ardour was donation only, and the switch to the pay tunnel had a dramatic impact on the revenue flow. Obviously that was then, this is now, and they may not be the same.
If the revenue was growing, maybe I’d feel differently, but it’s not: it is extremely steady state, and there isn’t any room for “error” that doesn’t impact mine and @x42’s daily life.
In that case what about a split test. Make an AI allowed branch and see how people like it, if it seems like it’s accepted by the community then it can be merged into main. If it’s unpopular or leads to issues then shut it down.
Windows embracing AI was what made me switch to Linux, and doing so taught me a lot. While it still doesn’t force me to use “AI” nonsense, it was crushing to see the devs embrace it without a second thought. Regardless, at least I had Ardour.
I was really happy moving to it after spending a few years with Reaper. Even if the kernel itself was sketchy, at least the software I directly used had more respect for artists, myself included. Recommending the project and continuing to donate was an easy decision.
Now that both have taken less than admirable stances on the fascist theft machine (no, I won’t apologize for that phrasing), I guess I’ll be looking for alternatives going forward. I’ll continue to use Linux and an older version of Ardour in the meantime, but here’s hoping.
I don’t know why I’m leaving this reply, to be honest. I guess I want to say something of substance before heading out, but why reiterate the problems baked in to “generative” “AI” when some smartass will always emerge with supposed ends to justify the means. Spoiler alert: They haven’t, and any upside very likely isn’t so to begin with.
All this talk over what is or isn’t a “good” or “worthwhile” use while ignoring baseline facts that haven’t changed, and can never change. As this brash but very accurate post echos: I’m tired. I’m so, so tired. The same conversation with different people, hopelessly going in the same circles over and over to find a “reasonable” middle ground, plugging their ears to what remains persistent. The world is not black and white, but some individual parts of it can be. At the very least, there is a point at which no upside should outweigh the detractor(s), and “AI” surpassed it years ago (soon after being envisioned, if you ask me).
Ardour has been endlessly useful since I started my journey with it. The software I use means a lot to me, and it hurts to abandon another workstation I’ve grown to love. I should have seen this coming when the conversation of ethics and principals, ironically, stayed firmly in step with legality. Because laws have never been for the worse, or influenced by the rich and powerful, right? I didn’t want to believe that was the cop out answer it sounded like. I also should have trusted my gut.
You (and a few others here) are winning my heart just because you’re willing to say the plain truth the way you see&feel it. I’m not gonna try to be a smartass, i’ll just say i think you’re overreacting.
First of all, don’t use the word fascism so litely…aldo i get what you’re trying to say, my great-grandfather(the guy who just disapeared from his home’s porch one day, whom i discovered in the victims of the holocaust list 70 years after) most probably woudn’t agree with you…he’ll most probably tell us that we don’t have a clue what we’re talking about .
Second is - if you shut your eyes and pray for ai to go away, it won’t. If you can’t see & appreciate the struggle of @Paul and @Robin here, i don’t know how to pursuade you. What i’m trying to say - the world has very quickly become like a very dangerous desert for soul made of fast entertainment, enormus expectations & greed, and you most probably won’t find better shelter for your artistic dreams anywhere but here. You shurely can also as easily answer in Lebowski style - “Well…that’s just your opinion, man.”
Anyways, that really is my opinion.
I will briefly share my thoughts on this for whatever it is worth
I think @paul and @x42 should do what they think is the right move for Ardour to be sustainable in the future. If I understood Paul’s original post correctly, it’s not as much as shoehorning as many features as quickly as possible into Ardour as it is about future maintainability. Ardour (from my limited understanding) is a primary source of income for Paul and Rebon. Sometimes you have to do what you have to do to support yourself and your family. You’re never going to make everyone happy no matter how hard you try.
I have very mixed emotions about AI. I use it extensively in both my professional and personal life.I am honestly having more fun than ever I had in my sysadmin role. I love using to implement certain parts of LogicalArdour. I walked away from LogicalArdour for a while, but with all the vibe coded clone DAWs, I am more motivated than I ever have been to work on it.I think having something that was original conceived and created by a human being with a cool story behind it would be a welcome change in our current landscape.
With all that said, I am also not tone deaf to some of the negative side effects of AI particularly when it comes to the environmnet. I recently moved to more a rural area within the last 6 months. My house sits above a hill side overlooking a river and is also surrounded by beautiful farmland and rolling hills. I was very upset when I heard they want to build not 1 but 2 data centers within ten miles of my residence.One of those data centers is supposed to be 6 miles donwstream from my house and it’s supposed to take over 500 acres of woods. I came out here for peace and tranquility not be surrounded by pollution and more industrialization. One of my next big purchases is going to an Nvidia RTX 5090 and some RAM so I can run this stuff at home. Not only would that cut reliance on big tech, but hopefully will discourage the building of data centers. I also despise tools like Suno where it’s “type prompt, get song”. Music is a big part of my life and to me it should be a very human experience. Music to me is meant to bring out certain emotions and knowing that a song was created by AI just doesn’t do it for me.
And with that last paragraph in mind, I just wanted to say I am more than a little annoyed by all the pearl clutching in this thread. How many of you use Linux? The kernel developers use LLMs to develop it. I was just watching a video where Linus himself said he likes the idea of using AI for coding. In fact here is the video here: https://youtu.be/3eGwsng4p24?si=yWOR2RcdALE2EpAG
I see some of you are wanting to move to other DAWs like Reaper. I know Justin Frankel historically has been against the use of AI however I know in one of the recent releases their were some plugins released and it was disclosed that were partially developed using AI. Even though the plugins were removed in a later release, it shows that Cockos is at least somewhat open to the idea of AI development.
Just to be clear, at the time of writing, and including the upcoming version of Ardour 9.9, Ardour itself does not contain any LLM generated code.
We cannot prevent users from interacting with Ardour via LLMs (via OSC, MIDI middle-ware, MCP…) and in some cases even encourage it since it enables visually impaired users to use Ardour and improves a11y. But that is a different story.