For some time ago, I needed to switch to Reaper from Ardour, and there’s just one thing that causes me to think about switching for permanently to this proprietary piece of software. It’s not-in-take MIDI editing. In Ardour, where you can edit notes in take just by switching to another tool, there was too many situations, when I tried to change velocity, change the length of a note in one take, but because the selection of previously changed notes stayed here, I changed the previous selection. In Reaper, just because you need to open a take to edit it, it wasn’t a problem, because it didn’t exist.
I have multiple suggestions to resolve it.
Add an opportunity to unselect EVERYTHING after pressing Ctrl+S
Double click on take to edit it.
Make a system, similar (in some ways) to other DAWs, when you need to open a take, to edit it. In this case, as main developers don’t want any pop-up windows to be in Ardour, takes will not be allowed to edit before opening
#1 is already fixed, although I’m not sure of the relationship to Ctrl-S.
#2 … not sure of the difference between pressing one key “e” to edit MIDI contents of a region and dbl-clicking the region … both have their pros and cons
Ok. If the selection will be unselected after a cursor is moved out of MIDI region, or after some other commonly used action, it’s fine.
I mean, before the double click, regions will be similar to ones in LMMS, but after - same as after pressing “e”, but with only clicked region. It’s kind of a way to add a focus on regions, where you can edit the only region you’re focused on