Cannot extract audio from video

I understand. I’ll try with official Mac os X version. Thank you

If you have problems on Mac with that, let me know, that I can help with. And on Linux. I Just don’t know enough about how it is packaged on Windows to be able to help there, sorry.

       Seablade

Many thanks Seablade. :slight_smile:
I’ll try it next week on my Imac.

For the moment, I can say I tried to open this file “I’m not ready video file (.MOV)” on Reaper : took 5/6 sec to load the video and the audio track
Trancoding is not finished yet on ardour4. But it’s not in my opinion a specific problem with Ardour but with Xjadeo and harvid/ffmpeg.

best regards

@CPascal

Note that on import the default method is to transcode it for best performance while editing. You can however tell it not to, and just use the linked file, but can have some issues ranging from either sync problems or less than smooth playback, etc. It depends on your computer and the codecs in questions as to whether or not you run into these issues, or how bad they are.

        Seablade

Depends of my computer ? Hp Pro CoreI 5 16 go ram nvidia 2 Go Yamaha MXGU ?

Sorry but it works with reaper, samplitude proX, N track studio.

I don’t know what SamX uses for a decoder, Reaper can use Quicktime or VLC. What does Ardour use? Is this customisable and does it even support MP4?

Ah its no MP4, its AVI. Nevermind my comment.

Not a pb, i’ll try again another day. Ardour4 is a great daw, but not for video post synchro for the moment.

@CPascal

I would recommend you look through my comment again, as I mentioned above, you can tell Ardour NOT to transcode a preview version (It is in the settings, either when you ‘Open Video’ or in the preferences for Ardour, can’t remember where) if you are comfortable with that, and instead use the exact file you give it. This is not the default, because when you are doing video post, it wouldn’t be unusual to end up with HUGE track counts, where every bit of performance on the computer can help and losing, which is one reason why transcoding is default in Ardour. And then when you export from Ardour you can tell it to export using the original media instead of the transcoded preview so that there is no difference in exported quality.

I have used Ardour a LOT for video post honestly, and Ardour4 is very good for this in all honesty, at least for what I am concentrated on (Dialog and SFX with using music someone else writes).

        Seablade

WAit :slight_smile:
tried and tried and tried again, and it depends of file. It’s only a codec problem.
Hurrah.

I can open and transcode some video files on Ardour4 and it works perfectly. Some of them cannot be opened on ardour4.

Ok seablade thank you. It’s only a pb of codecs, i’ll do more beta testing and I will give all details on forum. (Ardour4 on Windows 8.1 pro)

Ardour 4.0.397 (ancient nightly build) works perfectly. I can open audio AND video files, I can extract audio from video; I have video timeline etc.
Ardour 4.0-415 (02.06.2015 version) doesn’t work and crashes everytime i try to open video files…

SO if you can fix it once for all, Ardour4 will be one of the best DAW on the market. Stable, Midi and audio, Aui Vsti Ladspa, multicore, 64bits, for Linux Mac os X and Windows :wink:

CPascal can you post an issue to Mantis for the devs? Click on the bug tracker link at the top, and include the details about the videos you tried as well as the versions that worked and the ones that didn’t. Thanks.

        Seablade

Of course.

done :slight_smile:

HI seablade. Tried several (1 hundred times :)) ? with all my computers) and I think I found the cause of this problem.
When I record Ardour4 Sessions on USB external HD I obtain video and timeline but never audio extraction. USB external HD is too low
I tried again but on internal HD and it simply works on my 2 PCs.

For audio sessions we can use Ardour4 serssions on external HD
For video syncro we must have internal HD or very fast HD

Tried 5 min ago with a HUGE video file and it works :wink:

Resolved/ Closed.
sorry for any convenience.