Tried to read through as much this conversation as I could before realizing just how much there was to read. I am grateful that you are being thoughtful and deliberative regarding your use of Ai. I am both very sympathetic to the idea of not buying into the narrative of inevitability or putting one’s head in the sand completely as to the realities of what is going on in the world. With things moving so fast, the reality is that it is impossible to be too confident that one is making the right call.
As someone that doesn’t code proficiently, I have made significant use of Cursor to get things done that I would never be capable of otherwise, and that nobody else has tackled. It makes a huge difference in my world, but it took me a long time to start doing it, and I still have reservations.
As someone making music that wants to both loop in an Ableton-style way and record more professionally, the notion of having Ai assist in polishing the looping feature that I think it is safe-to-say, does not personally interest you a lot, is extremely tempting.
And as someone that is learning what he can about audio, I would actually love some ability to be able to integrate some sort of Ai-assisted mixing. I say this in the sense that I would view that sort of thing like a Lightroom Preset or various “smart” features. I have never found that such things ever give me the final result that I want, but they help me get closer to where I want to be without wasting so much time. To me, mixing and mastering are mixed art/technical skills. To the extent that they are technical, using Ai to learn is highly appealing to me. To the extent they are art, I think that I would be in the majority of people that would not just be content with what the Ai says, and I would do my own work to finish. It is such a massive problem for musicians in general that they don’t get product out the door, because they lack the time, expertise and motivation to learn how to do these things on their own. Obviously, mixing and mastering engineers have a perspective at play as well, but I feel like very few people who would otherwise use mixing and mastering professionals would change their mind. The people who do this best are the best for a reason, and I think they will continue to be.
I think that I would address the code quality issues by using rules and pointing the LLM at your existing code-base as the model for “good code”, and otherwise spell out the details of the approaches that you prefer/avoid. If you’re able to use local models (to generate your own code and/or assist with mixing, etc.), which I’ve only been able to do in part so far, I think that is far less objectionable. But, I also respect your viewpoint that you don’t want to go that way.
Finally, as a recovering lawyer, I definitely am glad that you are keeping your eye on legal developments and not just ignoring them. My own personal view is that, for better or worse, we are probably going to get more-and-more Ai-friendly precedent, not only because of what we’ve seen so far, but also because of the difficulty of proving sourcing, etc. I also wonder if, regardless of the precise developments in the law, if your current model of charging for compiled builds would really need to change. Perhaps the licensing would have to change and/or be impacted, but if you approach it from a “builds and support” is the product, it feels like it would continue to remain viable even if the details of the licensing changed.
Anyhow, that’s my input, for whatever it’s worth. Thank you for your ongoing development and thoughtful stewardship of this product.