“I’m as mad as hell and I’m not going to take this anymore!” ![]()
Just to be clear, at the time of writing, and including the upcoming version of Ardour 9.9, Ardour itself does not contain any LLM generated code.
We cannot prevent users from interacting with Ardour via LLMs (via OSC, MIDI middle-ware, MCP…) and in some cases even encourage it since it enables visually impaired users to use Ardour and improves a11y. But that is a different story.
Zwei Seelen wohnen, ach! in meiner Brust…
Glad it was not me who brought up a story about a pact with the devil ![]()
„Tiefe Brunnen muss man graben, wenn man klares Wasser will".
…and the rest of chorus is also applicable to the current situation. Nothing gets any easier, i’m affraid
.
Why do you ask? The point of that paragraph is to state that there are other alternatives to Ardour that are available that do not (appear to, I could be wrong) have AI (or have reverted AI related changes). The three that I mentioned are free (in either “price” and/or “speech”).
Unfortunately, there is a link between the Silicon Valley “Techno-Capitalists” of today (that push AI) and the Fascist parties that started World War I. I found this out through Adam Neely, who also explains why AI is different from other music technologies (like MIDI). I have mentioned the video and a summary of the relevant section of the video in the past, if you want to learn more.
Regarding revenue:
If you are “extremely wary of doing stuff that is basically experimenting” with your finances, then I seriously suggest not using AI. As I mentioned above, companies that allow AI in their products results in an negative perception of the resulting software and its developers, as well as people canceling their subscriptions. In fact, there is one person reacting to your Mastodon post right now claiming that they will cancel their subscription if you allow a permissive AI policy.
I ask because the Linux Kernel makes use of LLMs so do the other two main operating systems. Also Reaper is not free in speech or beer.
So in summary if Ardour adopts AI, some subscribers will leave, but its much less likely anyone will leave because Ardour doesn’t use AI, in fact it may even gain some users / subscribers as a result. Therefore In the absence of an existential threat to Ardour which requires that the developers do adopt AI, the choice would seem quite obvious?
This post was flagged by the community and is temporarily hidden.
Posting that poll I’m also thinking about the possibility of having AI helping filter and redirect faster and more efficiently bug reports, that wouldn’t mean outputting code into de program itself but maybe can be helpful for the guys better managing our reports, which I can guess are not ideally communicated by ourselves most of the time?
I wonder how many bug reports are themselves AI generated now?
The idea of LLM generated code introducing bugs that AI then creates bug reports for, after which AI fixes, is mildly hilarious to me
I’ve avoided posting in this thread because I don’t have much to offer in the way of meaningful input.
But
I would prefer Ardour just continue on its current non-AI slow and steady path. There’s no massively technical, philosophical reason on offer or anything. I just like the idea of software being human-centric non-corporate free/libre/open source and so on. It reflects an ideal that I personally would like to see be as real as possible. Be the change you want to see. And so on.
Other reasons for maintaining the non-AI status quo mentioned here seem perfectly reasonable too in my opinion.
I don’t use LLMs myself, neither at work nor in my private life, because I fucking hate so many aspects of the modern western world’s way of life and refuse to get on board without careful consideration first, but wholly understand their appeal and why others find their use incredibly useful and productive etc.
For context, I use a dumb phone as my daily (my smart phone has essentially been relegated to small tablet for internet banking / offline Organic Maps sat nav status), run Linux on old hardware for everything I do (might switch to BSD though…?), buy music on Bandcamp, drive an old 1.0 petrol car from 1999 as my daily, etc. I’m a luddite basically. Mainly because my life is simple and humble and what I have works and what I do makes me happy and content and why change something if I’m happy and content.
I’d have preferred if “at any degree” wasn’t there in the question and instead there were more than 2 options with different levels of conviction/reasoning. Don’t get me wrong, I trust the judgement of Robin and Paul, but I’m inclined to not vote due to the wording as it stands.
(And is support meant to imply financial only, or non-financial? Mentioning just to be thorough. Maybe repurposing Fitzgerald and Moon’s Building Blocks model in some ways to think of what support could mean, for example.)
I can’t vote in a query formulated like this. It’s to simplified to me.
Basicaly, i came here by running away from increasingly privacy disrespecting Windows and things like Copilot (amongst other thing i don’t like in Windows realm). I don’t like the fact that Linus is bending his attitude under the pressure of sheer multitude of new “devs” with tons of merge requests, and attractive simplificaton of development & reverse engineering process.
Most of all i don’t like things like Suno - to be more precise - i don’t want any of that on my personal computers.
So, red flag for me would be if Ardour in any way would made easier for AI to look around my stuff, acquire my midi or audio files etc. I’ve seen what generative AI does to artists, i don’t want it even near my radius. Not to mention i’m disgusted with fake authorship things like Suno propel and support.
If @Paul and @Robin use AI to develop something for Ardour, like a new feature etc isn’t really my concern. I can tell you what i’d most likely do if i was a dev. Surely i wouldn’t merge anything in my project that i don’t understand completely, especially in a project like this, which came this far without AI. I’d use it to learn or get some variant of code for features i have no clue how to make/resolve, but i’d definitely not use AI generated and uninspected code. If i’d ever put in portion of AI code, i’d do it for completely separated feature from the rest of the programm, and i’d keep that section of code visibly marked in every way possible.
…and also there’s the environmental issue for which i wasn’t even aware that it’s that severe. I’m still not sure how it measures against all other human-made polluters, but it sure doesn’t look pretty.
I wonder how are people expecting to differentiate AI-software from AI free software in closed source projects.
Because if the reason is “I will notice” which is way of saying “I will judge the GUI/speed of development” I have no doubts whatsoever private companies will find a way for their users not knowing.
The Reaper plugins were obviously developed using Claude assistant for GUIs (by the way, it is obvious when you have already used Claude for generating GUIs). Tuta was open and upfront about, but it always leaves me wondering. If Tuta was closed-source nobody will know and if the ports of Reaper were to be given a design framework and any other visual scaffolding done with another AI I don’t know how would have people noticed it.
How are (we the) people expecting to differentiate AI-software from non-AI software?
I saw a post on Mastodon months back asking about if to promote or talk about AI-developed open source plugins or not.
Of course, the closed source plugins (which are published EVERY DAY) nobody says anything about.
Just for context I have already seen at least three developers selling closed source plugins which were obviously vibe-code (and not very good, I might add).
Not trying to bring heat to the thread, but I do believe it is an important point to think about.
Moderators have removed the poll.
We do want a discussion and opinions instead of a polarizing two option poll on a complex subject.
Sure.
otoh for folks like me, who are rather against the usage, if possible! , it was a way to quickly say: Won’t be the end of the world either, even if in general i am not a fan of ai.
As far i understand this thread most seem to see it that way (even if against, not the end of the world) and the poll seem to have given that first impression too.
Once at it: For a few days i wonder if there really is no way to find someone who is interested in working on the Wayland problem. But that is so obvious, that it probably was considered already.
No need to comment on that, it is just one of the things which goes through my mind while thinking about it. There will be reasons (it’s not too hard to come up with some reasonable ones myself).
That is indeed a special case.
Wayland is free/libre software. The code is out in the open (no licensing issues), and adding Wayland support to Ardour’s ydk would largely be inspired by gdk4 (which was written by humans).
I estimated it would take me 3-5 months to do this manually (plus a month of cursing), during which time Ardour development would stall. I’d rather work on actual audio software.
I could see that certain infrastructure parts could benefit from LLM assistance, while keeping the main project separate and free of generated code.
The problem is: Where to draw the line? So right now I’d rather not do that without further consideration.
I’m kinda surprised the ratio is like that. I’d sorta expect 80:20, given (what I consider to be) the substantial 14k/month from subscribes currently. Alrighty then. Do what you feel is best.
As a side-note, you mentioned in that recent Linux Lads (ep. 168) podcast that Paypal takes something like 70k yearly???
Holy hell, that is a crime, no matter the “service” being performed. … Any ‘reasonable’ way to transition away from that first? Jesus. Wild.