Hi all,
what do you think is currently the best open source plugin that can be used in Ardour to realistically simulate the sound of an acoustic guitar in a MIDI track?
[Ardour on Linux]
Thank you,
a.
So much of making a virtual guitar sound “real” is in the MIDI programming. There are tons of guitar sample libraries out there, if you have Kontakt I really like the sound of the Orange Tree Samples guitars. There’s probably also some available for Decent Sampler.
Pianoteq has a classical guitar patch which sounds quite good. If you’re using linux, no prob as pianoteq is native - it is pricey though but I think you can try a demo version. Note that pianoteq is not sample based but a model, so the plugin is pretty lightweight. Check for yourself the sound samples on their website:
https://www.modartt.com/guitar
Sample
If you’re looking for something open source, check out the Nylon,Clean, or Steel Guitar (Steel sounds the most realistic) that comes with x42 General MIDI Synth, x42 General MIDI Synth
Then stick a reverb (I am using Gx Verb which part of the Guitarix plugins lv2 bundle:GitHub - brummer10/GxPlugins.lv2: A set of extra lv2 plugins from the guitarix project.) before the fader on the effects chain and I think it sounds pretty good IMO.
Honestly, it would probably be easier, cheaper, faster, and definitely sound more authentic to find some kid who lives nearby and have them play a real guitar for you. Maybe contact a guitar teacher and see if any of his students want a free studio experience.
This may be a little off-course from what you were requesting, but perhaps we can compare this to using a theoretical hardware synth that takes MIDI and returns excellent guitar performances. In practice, you could use your Linux/Ardour setup, send MIDI to this beast, return audio and have what you want. Fortunately this beast does exist, but unfortunately it is another computer. MIDI from Ardour/Linux to another system that receives MIDI and runs instances of AAS Strum or AmpleSound guitars. I haven’t seen anything from the open source community that comes close to these two. To tackle this you will need to determine if the priority is getting a great guitar track or being exclusively Linux.
h
Here is a small Fingerpicking and strumming example
Load ac-guitar-test.ardour from the unzipped folder.
I used Fluida in this project (on Linux), if you don’t have fluida replace it with a plugin that can load soundfonts and load Acoustic Guitars JNv2.sf2 from the soundfont folder (in the the unzipped folder) into your plugin.