Could we have a clip list for radio montage/podcast-production?

  1. Ardour doesn’t really do “file names”. The things that have names are Regions (and in fact, the Sources List is technically a list of Regions that are slightly special in that they represent the whole file(s) they refer to. Because file names are not generally important inside Ardour other than as a starting point for naming regions, we don’t offer a way to rename files, and because these specific “whole file” regions are intended to act as proxies for the files, you can’t rename them either. Once a region is in the region list or in a playlist (i.e. in a track), you can rename them from there.

  2. I don’t understand that this one means, or what it is you want to do but cannot do at present.

1 Like

I suppose you could do this with ranges, and you’ll see that you can find all the ranges in your tracks in the Editor List as well.

What you’re asking for is very similar to what an NLE (video editor) does: you have a media library and from there you can select ranges and assign them names or star them as favorites. You can create named ranges in Ardour that would function similarly to this, but you can only create ranges in regions that are on your tracks.

1 Like

thanks for the reply.
Sorry for the confusion. I might not be using the correct terminology.

1: That I can understand then. I’d just like to be able to rename the clips held in my imaginary “Clip-list” (the one I’d like to see in ardour). Like, for instance, if I have imported a long file from a tho hour interview about i.e. coffee-tables into my DAW, and then go through it picking the places where the person interviewed says relevant stuff regarding oak coffee tables (might be one placed at 0:33:00 and one placed at 01:56:11) - then in the “Clip list” (NB: the one I imagine, not the “region list”, I could call the first clip Oak-tables 1 and the second Oak tables 2, or something like that, so they’d be easily found again and dragged onto the tracks for the montage.

2: I would like for the “Clip list” (again, referring to my imagined feature, not the current suggested solution of the sources list) to only hold or refer to the clips I’ve selected from the imported tracks, so I’d be able to do as described above, and then later browse the selected regions and drag them back in to the different tracks.

Cheers. This might be a viable solution. I’ll try that right away!
I thought I’d tried that before, actually, but might have done something wrong the first time around.

Maybe not, though, because the ranges list doesn’t show the ranges’ names, only their times. Whoops, actually it does but you have to drag out the editor list window quite a way to the left in order to see them. But you can see them!

haha - yeah, I discovered that while you wrote this.
Well, here’s to hoping that this can become a feature one day! :grin:

If anybody succeeds in making this, Ardour could really become a killer podcast DAW as well as the great music DAW it already is.

wow, yeah!
Nice! - I still miss the ability to cut/copy the selected ranges, hold them somewhere and put them back in, though. This just lets me navigate the track, it seems. I’d still have to put all the useful clips far off to the left, and move them back once I need them, risking to mess up other transitions along the way.

I think you really want to use the region list. Tell me why not :slight_smile:

1 Like

Could you just make a track for your “useful clips” and give them all marker names or range names? Then you’d have a track full of keepers that you can just drag down to other tracks as needed. You can keep the track hidden until you need it.

What’s the difference between that and the region list (other than that the region will likely contain some extra stuff) ?

The region list would have everything but I think Lindisfarne wants an easily accessible collection of “favorites” or best clips. As I mentioned above, this is how NLEs work: you have a media library (equivalent to the sources list in Ardour) and from there you determine which regions (aka clips) will be added to your project, and then you review your clips and create named ranges, assigning keywords or marking them as favorites. Those are the clips that will make it into your video.

I could see how this workflow could be useful for podcasting. Some video editors will do a stringout of favorite clips on one track that they can then copy/paste or drag/drop into their timeline. So that might be handier than having to navigate through the region list or even a range or marker list.

1 Like

I suppose I’m unclear what these favorites are. Introductory voice over and music? Bullets and filler audio? They presumably are not taken from the actual contents of a given podcast, because I would not think you would re-use them. If you’re editing new per-episode material, why not just edit in a track? Why go through the extra step of putting things that are the actual new material in a separate list?

I think the key is in Lindisfarne’s item number 2 above “the ability to hold actual clippings from the long files in the tracks (like a handful of good quotes from a two-hour interview)”

I have about 30 hours of video from which I’m building a one-hour documentary. Having the ability to create named ranges and favorites is indispensable. I think that’s what Lindisfarne is after and I do think it’s possible to recreate this in Ardour with ranges and markers but those items have to be on your “timeline” first (you need to put them on a track or tracks). In an NLE you can create those ranges and favorites on items that are not actually in your timeline, and I think Lindisfarne was hoping for something similar where you could create a collection of favorite clips in a bin.

1 Like

Well, how do you create them in an NLE without first putting them somewhere that you can trim/edit them from the original material?

You have a source viewer in an NLE that allows you to view any clip in your project and create ranges in it without dropping it into your timeline (kind of like how Ardour allows you to listen to files in the import window). You can assign names or keywords to those ranges, making it easy to find, for example, every clip that has a statue in it, or every clip that is an interview, or every clip that is b-roll of a beach. You can create smart bins that automatically organize all your clips by keywords, so all the clips that show a beach are automatically organized into a bin, making them easy to find when you’re assembling your timeline and you need a shot of a beach.

You can also mark clips as favorites or “good takes,” which makes finding your best material easy.

1 Like

Thanks for clarifying! This sounds exactly like what I’m looking for.
My podcasts are more related to the audio documentary style of shows like “This American Life” than it is to the shows where a number of people are sat around a table, talking.

This has been my solution until now (minus the hidden part, I’ll try that now :slight_smile: ), but we have had to use another DAW for work, called Hindenburg, that had this other feature - the list -, and I really fell for this nice and tidy way to keep my favourited/picked clips in view, while I was working on the tape.Then I also discovered that Pro Tools had it, so I figured it might be useful for musicians too somehow.
In Hindenburg they call it “Clip Board” - as described in this video: Hindenburg tutorial - Organize - YouTube (video prompted to start where he describes what it is).

Thanks for the persistence! I have now learned a bit more about the region list (range list was a bad one), and it does seem to go a long way in this regard :smiley: Especially when used in tandem with Bhurleys suggestion that I quoted here also.

The list is more bloated and the process is a bit less easy than in Hindenburg (the latter maybe just a question of practice) but it keeps me using Free Software, and for that I am grateful :slight_smile:

Back again after having used the suggested method some more - I hope it has helped me getting the terminology a bit clearer in describing what I’m still missing:

It works :slightly_smiling_face:- but a way to do it without having every cut in a range on the list, as it is now with the regions list, and without having to hide/un-hide a hidden saver-track constantly as I go along, and rather just have a list of something like “range-clipboard” that could work by holding it’s own autonomous copy of selections made in ranges on the tracks, would be great.

I just Bounce to Source List for each range that I want to save so that all of the sounds I need to use are in one list. Not ideal, but better than using the region list especially if you might use a sound a number of times (Region list becomes bloated as you say) and also if you don’t yet want to have the sound on your timeline (region deleted from the timeline disappears from the Region List). I like the Pro Tools Clip List where ‘real’ sound files are in bold type and clips (ranges/regions, just part of a sound file) are in normal type. You can see the difference at a glance but all my sounds are together. For our Recording students it’s not an issue, but for the students on creative music tech (sonic arts etc.) courses it seems to be the best workaround.

1 Like

Thank you, thank you, thank you!!!
this is a life saver!
NOW I understand the sources-list and am able to use it. Ardour is a power-DAW!

This topic was automatically closed 91 days after the last reply. New replies are no longer allowed.